UN: Russia and Ukraine are to blame for nursing home attack

Audrey J. Powers

WASHINGTON — Two weeks immediately after Russia invaded Ukraine in February, Russian forces assaulted a nursing residence in the jap region of Luhansk. Dozens of elderly and disabled patients, several of them bedridden, were trapped inside of devoid of h2o or electricity.

The March 11 assault established off a fire that unfold through the facility, suffocating people who could not go. A compact selection of patients and employees escaped and fled into a nearby forest, finally having aid after walking for 5 kilometers (3 miles).

In a war awash in atrocities, the attack on the nursing household near the village of Stara Krasnyanka stood out for its cruelty. And Ukrainian authorities positioned the fault squarely on Russian forces, accusing them of killing a lot more than 50 susceptible civilians in a brutal and unprovoked assault.

But a new U.N. report has identified that Ukraine’s armed forces bear a substantial, and most likely equal, share of the blame for what happened in Stara Krasnyanka, which is about 580 kilometers (360 miles) southeast of Kyiv. A several times just before the assault, Ukrainian soldiers took up positions inside of the nursing house, successfully generating the setting up a target.

At the very least 22 of the 71 sufferers survived the assault, but the exact amount of people killed continues to be unfamiliar, in accordance to the United Nations.

The report by the U.N.’s Office environment of the Large Commissioner for Human Legal rights does not conclude the Ukrainian soldiers or the Russian troops committed a war crime. But it mentioned the struggle at the Stara Krasnyanka nursing household is emblematic of the human legal rights office’s concerns around the potential use of “human shields” to avert armed forces functions in specified places.


This tale is aspect of an ongoing investigation from The Affiliated Push and the PBS sequence “Frontline” that features the  War Crimes Enjoy Ukraine interactive experience  and an forthcoming documentary.


The aftermath of the attack on the Stara Krasnyanka residence also presents a window into how both equally Russia and Ukraine shift immediately to set the narrative for how occasions are unfolding on the floor — even when individuals events might nevertheless be shrouded by the fog of war. For Ukraine, retaining the higher hand in the fight for hearts and minds will help to ensure the continued circulation of billions of bucks in Western navy and humanitarian support.

Russia’s usually indiscriminate shelling of apartment buildings, hospitals, faculties and theaters has been the principal trigger of the war’s 1000’s of civilian casualties. Ukraine and its allies, together with the United States, have rebuked Moscow for the deaths and injuries and termed for these dependable to be brought to justice.

But Ukraine also will have to abide by the global principles of the battlefield. David Crane, a former Defense Department official and a veteran of several intercontinental war criminal offense investigations, reported the Ukrainian forces might have violated the rules of armed conflict by not evacuating the nursing home’s residents and personnel.

“The bottom-line rule is that civilians are not able to intentionally be specific. Period. For whichever rationale,” Crane said. “The Ukrainians put all those persons in a predicament which was a killing zone. And you can’t do that.”

The Associated Press and the PBS collection “Frontline,” drawing from a wide range of sources, have independently documented hundreds of attacks throughout Ukraine that most likely constitute war crimes. The wide greater part seem to have been fully commited by Russia. But a handful, such as the destruction of the Stara Krasnyanka care residence, indicate Ukrainian fighters are also to blame.

The 1st stories in the media about the Stara Krasnyanka nursing house mainly mirrored statements issued by Ukrainian officials far more than a week immediately after the combating finished.

Serhiy Haidai, the governor of Luhansk, declared in a March 20 put up to his Telegram account that 56 folks had been killed “cynically and deliberately” by “Russian occupiers” who “shot at shut assortment from a tank.” The place of work of Ukraine’s prosecutor common, Iryna Venediktova, mentioned in a statement issued the identical day that 56 elderly persons died due to the “treacherous actions” of the Russian forces and their allies. Neither assertion stated irrespective of whether Ukrainian troopers had entered the residence right before the fighting began.

The Luhansk regional administration, which Haidai leads, did not answer to requests for comment. The Ukrainian prosecutor general’s business advised the AP on Friday that its Luhansk division continues to investigate Russia’s “indiscriminate shelling and forced transfer of persons” from the nursing property. About 50 clients were being killed in the assault, the workplace mentioned, fewer than it stated in March. The prosecutor general’s business did not instantly respond to the U.N. report, but said it also is wanting into regardless of whether Ukrainian troops had been in the residence.

Moscow-backed separatists have been preventing Ukrainian forces for eight yrs in the primarily Russian-talking japanese industrial heartland, the Donbas, which contains the Luhansk and Donetsk locations. They have declared two unbiased “people’s” republics, which were being recognized by Russia just just before the war started. Immediately after the invasion, these separatist fighters came under Russian command.

Viktoria Serdyukova, the human legal rights commissioner for the Luhansk separatist governing administration, explained in a March 23 statement that the Ukrainian troops were responsible for casualties at the nursing dwelling. The people experienced been taken hostage by Ukrainian “militants” and lots of of them were “burned alive” in a fire started off by the Ukrainians as they were being retreating, she said.

The U.N. report examined violations of global human rights legislation that have happened in Ukraine considering the fact that Russia invaded on Feb. 24. The Stara Krasnyanka attack totals just two paragraphs in the 38-site report. While short, this short portion is the most in depth and independent assessment of the incident that is been manufactured general public.

The Stara Krasnyanka part is primarily based on eyewitness accounts from staff who survived the assault and data presented by kinfolk of residents, according to a U.N. official who wasn’t approved to discuss publicly and spoke on situation of anonymity. The Workplace of the Substantial Commissioner for Human Rights is still performing to fully document the situation, the formal said. Amid the remaining queries are how lots of men and women were killed and who they had been.

At the beginning of March, in accordance to the U.N. report, “when lively hostilities drew nearer to the treatment home,” its management asked for frequently that local authorities evacuate the people. But an evacuation wasn’t feasible simply because Ukrainian forces were considered to have mined
the bordering spot and blocked roadways, the report explained. The household is constructed on a hill and is near a vital freeway, which designed the place strategically critical.

On March 7, Ukrainian soldiers entered the nursing household, according to the U.N. Two days later on, they “engaged in an trade of fire” with the Moscow-backed separatists, “although it continues to be unclear which aspect opened hearth to start with,” the report explained. No staff or citizens were being hurt in this to start with exchange.

On March 11, 71 residents and 15 staff remained in the property with no access to drinking water or electrical energy. That morning, the Luhansk separatist forces, which the U.N. referred to as “Russian-affiliated armed groups,” attacked with major weapons, the report mentioned.

“A hearth begun and distribute across the care household, even though the fighting was ongoing,” in accordance to the U.N. An unspecified amount of individuals and staff fled the house and ran into a nearby forest and ended up sooner or later achieved by the separatist fighters, who gave them support, according to the U.N.

A correspondent for the state-owned Russia-1 news channel acquired accessibility to the war-ravaged dwelling just after the fight and posted a online video to his Telegram account in April that accused the Ukrainian troopers of making use of “helpless old people” as human shields.

The correspondent, Nikolai Dolgachev, was accompanied into the developing by a man discovered in the movie as a Luhansk separatist soldier who goes by the connect with signal “Wolf.” The in depth injury to the setting up, both of those inside and out, is visible in the movie. A entire body is laying on the flooring. The AP confirmed that the place in the movie posted by Dolgachev is the treatment residence by comparing it to other video clips and photographs of the developing.

Dolgachev reported the Ukrainian troops established up a “machine gun nest” and an anti-tank weapon in the property. In the video, he stops amid the rubble inside of the making to rest his hand on the anti-tank weapon, which he improperly named a Tor. The Tor is a Russian-produced floor-to-air missile.

Ian Williams, a army qualified at the Heart for Strategic and International Scientific tests, reviewed the video and stated the weapon is an RK-3 Corsar, a Ukrainian-built moveable anti-tank guided missile.

Even though the opposing sides blame every single other for the Stara Krasnyanka tragedy, the grim actuality is that substantially of the war in Ukraine is becoming fought in populated regions, expanding the probable for civilian casualties. These deaths and accidents grow to be nearly inevitable when the civilians are caught in the line of fireplace.

“The Russians are the negative guys (in this conflict). That is very apparent,” Crane explained. “But everybody is accountable to the legislation and the rules of armed conflict.”


Affiliated Press writer Lynn Berry in Washington and photographer Zoya Shu in Berlin contributed to this report.


EDITOR’S Take note — The Related Push and “Frontline” are gathering information from organizations including the Centre for Information and facts Resilience,  Bellingcat, the International Partnership for Human Legal rights, the Ukrainian Health care Heart, Human Rights Look at and Physicians for Human Rights to inform the War Crimes Enjoy Ukraine interactive experience.


Get in touch with AP’s investigations workforce at [email protected].

Next Post

Malcolm’s Dining Room Intro: How He Plans To Prioritize Vintage And Secondhand Pieces + An Exciting Personal Announcement

If you’ve been following along with my home renovation journey here on Emily’s blog, you know that I’ve accomplished quite a bit in my home over the last couple of years. I’ve completed a primary bedroom renovation, a somewhat unexpected bathroom overhaul, a life-changing home office makeover, and a slew […]
Malcolm’s Dining Room Intro: How He Plans To Prioritize Vintage And Secondhand Pieces + An Exciting Personal Announcement

You May Like